Andy solve an equation as shown below. What error did Andy make?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44b54/44b545aac153d8ce8efe5d60ec4ce1053c71a7ce" alt="Andy solve an equation as shown below What error did Andy make class="
Answer:
Step-by-step explanation:
Whatever you do to the left you must do to the right, he multiplied 12 but forgot to multiply the -4 on the left and the + 1 on the right by the number 12