How is this wrong? Reflect shape A in the x-axis.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0934e/0934edd8ca1cbe147bdde54ce5b65ac94d3e3460" alt="How is this wrong Reflect shape A in the xaxis class="
Answer:
Your answer is wrong because you reflected it over the y-axis, not the x-axis. To find the correct answer, plot a triangle with vertices at (1, -1), (4, -1) and (4, -3). Note that we switch the sign of the y-coordinate when reflecting over the x-axis.