Fifteen years ago, a man who owned vacant land granted an easement over that land, by deed of gift, to his neighbor for use as a shortcut to her cabin. The deed was silent concerning the easement's location; however, the neighbor used a 15-foot strip along the west side of the man's land. Last year, the neighbor's cabin was destroyed by fire. The neighbor rebuilt the cabin in a new location, as required by the local building code, and now wants to access the cabin from the east side of the man's land. The neighbor has told the man that she plans to relocate the easement on the east side of his land at her expense. The man has told the neighbor that the easement cannot be relocated. The man's land remains vacant. Does the man have the right to stop the neighbor from relocating the easement?
a) No, because the location of the easement was not fixed in the original grant.
b) Yes, because the grant of the easement was by deed of gift and without consideration.
c) No, because the neighbor would not have asked to relocate the easement if her cabin had not been destroyed by fire.
